Must Learn AI Security Part 6: Model Inversion Attacks Against AI

Chapter 6

Aug 23, 2023

This post is part of an ongoing series to educate about new and known security vulnerabilities against AI.

The full series index (including code, queries, and detections) is located here:

The book version (pdf) of this series is located here: https://github.com/rod-trent/OpenAISecurity/tree/main/Must_Learn/Book_Version

The book will be updated when each new part in this series is released.

What is a Model Inversion attack against AI?

A Model Inversion attack against AI refers to the process where an attacker attempts to reconstruct the original data used for training a machine learning model by only having access to the model's output. This type of attack poses a significant risk to the privacy of the data used for training the model.

How it works

A Model Inversion attack against AI works by exploiting the information leakage from the machine learning model's outputs to reconstruct or approximate the original training data. An attacker uses the model's predictions and confidence scores to iteratively refine their input to generate a close approximation of the original data.

Here's a step-by-step explanation of how a Model Inversion attack works:

Access to the model: The attacker needs access to the AI model, which can be through a public API, a stolen copy of the model, or any other means of interacting with the model's predictions.
Identifying target: The attacker selects a target individual or data point whose information they want to reconstruct from the model.
Generating initial input: The attacker starts with an initial input that could be random or based on some prior knowledge of the target domain.
Analyzing model outputs: The attacker inputs the generated data into the model and collects the model's predictions and confidence scores.
Refining input: Using the information from the model's outputs, the attacker iteratively refines the input data to maximize the model's confidence in the target label or class. This process involves optimization techniques like gradient descent or genetic algorithms.
Convergence: The attacker repeats steps 4 and 5 until the input converges to a close approximation of the target data point, or the confidence scores reach a certain threshold.
Reconstruction: The attacker now has a data point that closely resembles the original training data point, effectively compromising the privacy of the target individual or data point.

It's worth noting that Model Inversion attacks are more likely to be successful in cases where the model is overfitted, as it may have memorized specific training examples.

Types of Model Inversion attacks

There are two primary types of Model Inversion attacks against AI: the black-box attack and the white-box attack. Both types aim to reconstruct or approximate the original training data, but they differ in the level of access the attacker has to the AI model.

Black-box Model Inversion attack: In this type of attack, the attacker only has access to the model's input-output pairs, meaning they can input data and receive the corresponding predictions. However, they have no knowledge of the model's architecture, parameters, or the training data. The attacker generates inputs, analyzes the model's outputs, and iteratively refines the inputs based on the obtained information. This process continues until the attacker is able to approximate the original training data.
White-box Model Inversion attack: In a white-box attack, the attacker has more extensive access to the AI model, including its architecture, parameters (such as weights and biases), and possibly partial knowledge of the training data. This additional information allows the attacker to exploit the inner workings of the model more effectively and reconstruct the original training data with higher accuracy. In this scenario, the attacker can use gradient-based optimization techniques to maximize the model's confidence in the target label or class, ultimately converging to a close approximation of the target data point.

Both black-box and white-box Model Inversion attacks pose significant threats to the privacy of the data used in training AI models.

Why it matters

A Model Inversion attack against AI can lead to several negative consequences, mainly related to the breach of data privacy and potential misuse of sensitive information.

Some of these negative effects include:

Privacy violation: The primary concern of a Model Inversion attack is the potential exposure of sensitive information contained in the original training data. This can lead to a violation of individuals' privacy rights and cause harm to those whose data has been reconstructed.
Identity theft: In cases where the AI model involves personally identifiable information (PII), such as facial recognition or biometric data, a successful Model Inversion attack can lead to identity theft. Attackers may use the reconstructed data to impersonate individuals or gain unauthorized access to personal accounts and services.
Loss of trust: Model Inversion attacks can undermine trust in AI systems, as individuals and organizations become concerned about the security and privacy risks associated with using AI models trained on their data.
Legal and regulatory issues: Companies that experience a Model Inversion attack may face legal and regulatory consequences if they fail to protect users' data privacy according to established laws and regulations, such as the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) in the European Union.
Misuse of sensitive information: If the reconstructed data contains sensitive information, such as medical records or financial data, attackers could use this information for malicious purposes, including extortion, fraud, or targeted advertising.
Damage to reputation: An organization that suffers a Model Inversion attack may experience damage to its reputation, as users and clients may view the organization as having inadequate security and privacy measures in place.

Implementing robust security measures and following best practices can help protect AI systems from potential attacks.

Why it might happen

There are several reasons why someone might perform a Model Inversion attack against AI, which can range from monetary gain to competitive advantage or even just curiosity.

Some of these motivations include:

Financial gain: Attackers might attempt a Model Inversion attack to acquire sensitive information such as credit card details, social security numbers, or other financial data, which they could use for fraudulent activities or sell on the dark web.
Identity theft: In cases where the AI model involves personally identifiable information (PII), such as facial recognition or biometric data, attackers could use the reconstructed data to impersonate individuals, gain unauthorized access to personal accounts, or commit various forms of identity theft.
Competitive advantage: Competitors might perform a Model Inversion attack to gain insights into a company's proprietary data or trade secrets, which could give them a competitive advantage in the market.
Corporate espionage: Attackers might use Model Inversion attacks to gather sensitive information about a company's business strategies, product plans, or customer data, which could be used for corporate espionage or market manipulation.
Curiosity or intellectual challenge: Some attackers might be driven by curiosity or the intellectual challenge of successfully performing a Model Inversion attack, rather than having a specific malicious intent.
Exposing vulnerabilities: In some cases, security researchers or ethical hackers might perform a Model Inversion attack to demonstrate the potential vulnerabilities in an AI system and encourage the development of more secure and privacy-preserving AI models.

Real-world Example

Consider a facial recognition AI model that has been trained using a large dataset of individuals' images, along with their corresponding names. The AI model can recognize a person's face and output the person's name when given an input image.

An attacker, with no access to the original dataset, wants to uncover the image of a specific person, say, Meredith. The attacker starts by inputting random images into the model and analyzing the output probabilities of the model recognizing Meredith. By iteratively refining the input images and optimizing them based on the model's output probabilities, the attacker can eventually generate an image that closely resembles Meredith's face.

In this example, the attacker has successfully performed a Model Inversion attack, compromising the privacy of Meredith's image without having direct access to the original dataset. This highlights the importance of privacy-preserving techniques like differential privacy and secure multi-party computation in the development of AI models.

How to Mitigate

To mitigate the risk of Model Inversion attacks, privacy-preserving techniques like differential privacy, federated learning, and secure multi-party computation can be employed in the development and deployment of AI models.

How to monitor/What to capture

Detecting a Model Inversion attack against AI can be challenging, as the attacker often has limited access to the model and may not leave obvious traces. However, there are several indicators and activities you can monitor to detect potential Model Inversion attacks:

Unusual query patterns: Monitor the usage patterns of your AI model to identify any unusual or suspicious behavior. For instance, a high number of queries from a single source or an unexpected increase in queries during specific time periods could indicate a potential attack.
Atypical inputs: Keep an eye on the inputs provided to the model. If you notice a series of inputs that seem unusual, random, or unrelated to the typical use case, it could be an attempt to perform a Model Inversion attack.
High-confidence incorrect predictions: If your model starts generating high-confidence predictions that are incorrect or don't align with the expected output, it could be a sign that someone is trying to reverse-engineer the model by refining inputs based on the model's output probabilities.
Access logs and user behavior: Regularly review access logs and user behavior to identify any unauthorized or suspicious access to the AI model or attempts to exfiltrate model parameters.
Rate-limiting violations: Implement rate-limiting on your AI model's API to prevent excessive queries in a short period. Monitor for violations of these rate limits, as they could indicate an attacker trying to gather information for a Model Inversion attack.
Multiple failed login attempts: Track failed login attempts and unauthorized access attempts to your AI system, as attackers may try to gain access to the model itself or related resources to facilitate a Model Inversion attack.

Model Inversion attacks against AI involve exploiting information leakage from machine learning models to reconstruct or approximate the original training data. These attacks can compromise data privacy and lead to various negative consequences, such as identity theft, loss of trust, legal issues, and misuse of sensitive information.

[Want to discuss this further? Hit me up on Twitter or LinkedIn]
[Subscribe to the RSS feed for this blog]
[Subscribe to the Weekly Microsoft Sentinel Newsletter]
[Subscribe to the Weekly Microsoft Defender Newsletter]
[Subscribe to the Weekly Azure OpenAI Newsletter]
[Learn KQL with the Must Learn KQL series and book]
[Learn AI Security with the Must Learn AI Security series and book]